Monday, July 06, 2015
Crowd Trouble Halts Final In Semarang
With no league at the moment and an ongoing dispute between the government and the PSSI there is little in the way of football going on Indonesia. Except that is the Central Java Police District Cup.
Despite the heady title it has not been short of controversy with players attacking match officials when they perceive things don't go their way.
Anyway the competition has reached the final with Persis and PSIS going toe to toe in a home and away two legged affair.
The first leg was played on Saturday in Semarang, home of PSIS and finished, um, in a riot. The second leg is due to be played next weekend in Solo...but under what conditions is not clear.
As can be seen in the video
crowd control seems to consist of a few guys casually waving their arms in the air.
Sunday, July 05, 2015
Whistleblower Website Set Up In Indonesia
The Transition Team set up by the Ministry of Youth and Sports to change Indonesian football has come up with a website to encourage whistleblowers to report anything fishy they have encountered in the world of football.
The website www.laporsepakbola.com encourages people to report suspicious happenings on the field, rumours of match fixing, players waiting for salaries to be paid, dodgy performances by match officials and other stuff.
The folks behind the website they have been inundated with people providing information about misdeeds...it remains to be seen whether any information gets released to the general public though the site does claim summaries may well be released once in a while.
It will be interesting to see how this pans out. Does match fixing exist in Indonesian football? Has there been instances where match officials have been intimidated to provide the correct result? Will we ever find out or will any tales just be used as leverage in the future?
On paper a good idea and one long overdue. It is a shame it had to come from the government...
Sir Alex Ferguson To Get Involved In Indonesia Tournament?
The Independence Cup is slated to start in August and the organisers are getting very excited. So much so one of them has suggested they are trying to get Sir Alex Ferguson involved. Yep, you read that right. The wine loving Scot is apparently being wooed via his agent to help with the running of the cup being organised by a transition team on behalf of the government.
Apparently one member has been to Old Trafford to watch Manchester United play. What this means is not really made clear in the original
story beyond the 'look at me' factor.
The organisers would also like Fergie to give a coaching clinic.
Now far be it for me, a mere blogger, to pour cold water on this wonderful idea but a couple of things cling to mind. The English Premier League kicks off early August. Do these people really think Fergie is going to give up his box seat at Old Trafford to fly halfway round the world to get in involved in this competition. And the second thing? FIFA, it will be recalled has banned Indonesia from international football. You think Fergie will overlook that?
Mind you there would be one attraction for Fergie in coming to Indonesia. The local culture of Jam karet gels nicely with his own idea of Fergie time!
Will it happen? The story is on a par with Minangkabu from the short lived IPL trying to sign Dennis Bergkamp!
So far the following teams have been roped into the competition that may or may not happen.
Grup A: PSMS Medan, PSPS Pekanbaru, Persires Kuningan, Lampung FC, Kalteng Putra, Martapura FC
Grup B: Perserang, Cilegon United, Persika Karawang, PSIR Rembang, Persip Pekalongan, Persidago Gorontalo
Grup C: Persepam MU, Persebo Jaya Bondowoso, Madiun Putra, Persekap Pasuruan Jaya, Persatu Tuban, Persinga Ngawi. - See more at: http://ongisnade.co.id/2015/07/03/piala-kemerdekaan-diikuti-18-tim#sthash.FympuKEJ.dpuf
Group A - PSMS, PSPS, Lampung, Kalteng Putra, Martapura, Persires
Group B - Perserang, Cilegon United, Persika Karawang, PSIR, Persip Pekalongan, Persidago
Group C - Persepam MU, Persebo, Bondowoso, Madiun Putra, Persekap Pasuruan, Persatu Tuban, Persinga Ngawi
Saturday, July 04, 2015
Tsunami Boy's Tale Is A Tale Of Indonesian Football
Back in 2004 an eight year old lad was playing football in Aceh. Then came a tsunami that wiped out most of his family along with nearly 240,000 other people and he was pictured wearing a fake Portugal football shirt looking lost and forlorn. That was when the world first heard of Martunis.
The image of this tsunami survivor spread around the world even without Twitter and came to the attention of the Portugal football team. Cristiano Ronaldo and co flew to Aceh to meet the youngster still coming to terms with the tragedy he had narrowly survived.
More than a decade later and Martunis has signed for Portuguese side Sporting Lisbon's academy.
It is a heartwarming story but it is also the tale of Indonesian football and perhaps even South East Asian football. Martinus' wiki page suggests he spent some time with PSAP Sligi but how long and how many games he played for them is less clear.
, former coach of Indonesia U19, has posted an image on Twitter showing the young lad at trials for the national side in 2013...trials Martinus ultimately failed. It was probably just as well. Alumni from that side now have no professional career to look forward to thanks to the piss fest between the government and the PSSI that has resulted in Indonesian football being suspended.
Imagine Martinus had qualified and gone on to represent Indonesia at Under 19 level. His career would now be at a brick wall with little hope of going anywhere anytime soon. Indra Sjafri, while not recognising his talent, has done him a favour. If Martinus is going to develop as player he is better off away from the stifling atmosphere of a domestic game where some players pay the coach to play and some clubs don't even pay the players to pay.
Reading between the lines it seems Ronaldo has kept an eye on that young tsunami survivor and kept his interest quiet. We may never know the true story of the help one of the world's best players has provided, along with his team mates, but young lads from the boonies of Indonesia don't get picked up by European clubs willy nilly. Arthur Irawan made the move because his parents believed in him and had the wherewithall to help make his dream come true.
Too many talented players will never have that fortune. They are condemned to spend their career as mere chattel for others. And for all the potential people like to talk about in Indonesian football that is the bare truth. Evan Dimas' career has stalled, hostage to the bickering blighting the game.To develop a player must look beyond the teh botol
of his kampung and look overseas.
As news broke of Martunis' Portuguese adventure the sports minister was mocking FIFA. 'Where is FIFA now?' he asked. 'This is Indonesia' as if Indonesia sits astride a football legacy second to none. Yes, this is Indonesia where a player is not considered good enough for local teams, even if there were any, or their country but is good enough to move to one of the biggest clubs in Europe.
Thursday, July 02, 2015
Bangladesh Go Down Naturalisation Road
The Bangladesh Football Federation (BFF) yesterday started the
official procedure of naturalising three African footballers in order to
make them eligible for the Bangladesh national team.
The federation held talks with the three booters -- Ghana's Samad
Yussif, Guina's Ismael Bangoura and Nigeria's Kingsley Chigozie – heard
their demands and acquired their signatures on the provided forms, which
will be forwarded to the home ministry within a couple of days to
expedite the process.
The three booters in question are already eligible to apply for
Bangladeshi citizenship since each of them has already spent more than
four years continuously in this country. If the home ministry is
convinced, the procedure of naturalisation may take one month in the
least and six months at most. If citizenship is awarded, the federation
will then apply to the FIFA Status Committee to make them eligible to
represent Bangladesh national team.
BFF general secretary Abu Nayeem Shohag, who was present in the
meeting, reiterated that acquiring citizenship will not necessarily mean
these three players will walk into the national team.
“As per earlier talks between head coach Lodewijk de Kruif and the
three players, we sat today and took their consent. However, awarding
nationality doesn't mean they will get chance to play directly in the
national team. They will be included in preliminary squad and then they
will have to prove themselves to be included in the final squad,” Shohag
The players themselves were very positive about the prospect of
getting Bangladeshi citizenship and representing this country at the
“We have seen something positive in the meeting and requested them
(BFF) to start the process of the naturalisation,” said Chigozie, who
currently plays for Sheikh Russel KC.
Yussif, who has been playing for Abahani for the past seven seasons,
said he feels at home in Bangladesh and will give his full effort if
given the opportunity.
“Bangladesh is like my second home. I stay here seven to eight months
while spending rest of the time in Spain. As a professional player, I
give full effort on the pitch for my club and there will be no shortage
of effort when I play for the national team,” said the centre-back, who
is the oldest of the three at 31 years of age.
Bangoura, who is currently playing for Mohammedan and has already
scored nine goals in the ongoing premier league, said he is eager to
play for Bangladesh.
“We have had a good interaction with the BFF officials about the
nationality. I have agreed because I want to play for Bangladesh
national team and want to stay with Bangladesh football,” said the
However, the booters stated their queries regarding the nature of
nationality, the incentives that they might receive from BFF, their
status in the next domestic league and whether they will be provided
with air tickets to travel to their native countries.
The BFF officials
promised to provide them the same facilities that the local players of
the national team receive when they are with the national team while
promising that they might get extra benefits provided that they produce
some good performances for the team.
Tuesday, June 30, 2015
Ex Young Lion Gets JLeague Chance?
— If he goes on to eventually secure a contract
with J-League club Matsumoto Yamaga, Izwan Mahbud would become the first
Singaporean footballer to feature in top-flight Japanese football.
the Singapore national goalkeeper knows if he succeeds, he could also
be paving the way for more of the Republic’s best players to ply their
trade in Asia’s top leagues in what would be a huge boost for the
sport’s flagging fortunes here.
Yesterday, it was reported Matsumoto Yamaga
vice-president Yoshiyuki Kato had invited the 24-year-old for a trial.
Izwan knows a lot more is at stake than him trying to secure a deal.
I do go for trials, I’m sure many people in Singapore will be hoping to
see me succeed because they want to see Singaporean footballers playing
in top leagues overseas,” Izwan told TODAY. “We were proud to see
(Singapore national team-mate) Safuwan (Baharudin) playing for Melbourne
City in the (Australian) A-League, and his stint inspired us to want to
be like him and make it overseas.”
Izwan pulled off 18
saves to secure Singapore a shock 0-0 draw against four-time Asian
champions Japan — widely regarded as Asia’s best footballing nation for
the past two decades — in a 2018 World Cup qualifier in Saitama last
Tuesday. His performance also piqued interest in Japan about him and
But while he denied the likes of AC
Milan’s Keisuke Honda and Borussia Dortmund’s Shinji Kagawa, Izwan, who
plays his club football for Singapore-based Malaysian Super League side
LionsXII, admits Yamaga’s offer caught him off guard. “I did a short
online search after the (LionsXII’s) match (against ATM on Tuesday) and
found out more about the club. Their climb from the lower tiers into the
J-League over the past few years is impressive,” said Izwan.
Football Association of Singapore (FAS), which has been working to set
up playing stints and trials for top Singapore players in the J-League,
has not heard officially from Matsumoto Yamaga regarding the trials for
Izwan. But the FAS wants further discussions with the club and the
association’s relevant stakeholders, including sponsor Epson, on it. (No, no, please do not get involved. Why the hell does the FA need to talk to the sponsor? Perhaps they wanna look at KPIs and leverage on the hub to beccome a bespoke practioner of bullshit
Ahmad and V Sundramoorthy — they played for Dutch side FC Groningen
(1983 to 1985) and Swiss club FC Basel (1987 to 1988), respectively —
remain arguably Singapore’s most successful footballing exports.
who have tried to secure deals outside of South-east Asia include
former Singapore forwards Indra Sahdan, who had trials with United
States Major League Soccer side Real Salt Lake in 2007, and Noh Alam
Shah with Latvia’s Skonto Riga and England’s Notts County in 2005.
Earlier this year, Safuwan secured a three-month deal with Melbourne
City, while goalkeeper Hassan Sunny is now playing for Thailand’s Army
Full Steam Ahead For Independence Cup
Ok, so the headline is a bit tongue in cheek but someone has come out and talked about the Independence Cup, a competition much trumpeted by the Transition Team as how Indonesian football will be cleaned up in the future.
Ok so not many teams have entered so far. Apparently organisers wanted 30. At the moment? No one is saying for now though if just 12 or 14 fulfill the conditions the competition will proceed.
Ok so what are the criteria? Well, you will be relieved to know those fine fellows at BOPI will be the ones who decide who can enter and who can't, oh how they must enjoy all this power that has fallen in their laps. And yes, with all this responsibility they now have a new website
explaining what they do...the website is all in Indonesian but comes complete with an English motivational sentence from some guy I had to google.
Ok one of the clubs being rumoured to enter are Persibo. They were kicked out of professional football a couple of years back once the old PSSI returned and replaced the new PSSI to become the latest PSSI before the PSSI were unrecognised by the government. Get all that? Anyways, you may recall Persibo from their AFC Cup adventures but if you have forgotten here
you can recall their humiliating adventures.
Ok so how will it work? No one knows yet but it seems the idea is the competition will be based in a number of cities; Lampung, Medan, Serang, Bangkalan and Bali. And, umm, that is probably about it. A start date is 24 July but don't go booking any flights or hotels just yet.
Ok, with the competition being backed by the government it is unlikely there will be any issues with releasing the necessary permits and security clearances, unlike the Java Sunrise Cup which was cancelled because the security officials would not release the permits.
Eric Djemba Djemba, Crabs & One Month
My latest column for ESPNFC
looks at how FIFA's suspension of Indonesia is impacting football there.
Thursday, June 25, 2015
Ref Attacked In Indonesia. Again.
Have a good look at this picture and take into account the following.
1 - The image comes from a friendly tournament being held in Indonesia
2 - The tournament is being organised by the police in Central Java
3 - Indonesian football is currently suspended by FIFA
4 - Indonesian football frets and worries about match fixing or a referee mafia at the heart of the problems that plague the game
Do you get the impression anything will change anytime soon?
Tuesday, June 23, 2015
Young Persib Players Interested In Overseas Options
With Greg Nwokolo heading to Thailand with BEC Tero and Andik Vermansyah doing a job in Malaysia with Selangor, a couple of Persib players have expressed an interest in moving overseas.
Ahmad Jufriyanto and Taufiq were recently questioned about their future and while both players said they would continue to respect their deals with the champions if the opportunity to try their luck in a foreign country, and both specifically cited Malaysia, then they could be interested.
Another Persib player was in the news recently when Tony Sucipto announced he was developing a catering business. Meanwhile Montengren defender Vladimir Vujovic has also announced he is interested in examining his options.
It is refreshing to see young players being honest and up front about going abroad to further their careers. Staying in Indonesia does nothing to improve them as they get shunted from club to club where egotistical owners and tame coaches do their best to stifle their talent for their own interests.
The present crisis obviously is focussing minds that much more but the structural problems have been present for a long time now.
Monday, June 22, 2015
An Indonesian Ref
If you are going to name a lad to become a referee in Indonesia you can't go far wrong with Hardjowasito. In the Indonesian language a referee is known as a wasit!
People tend not to remember the names of match officials, only if they were truly awful. And that is how it should be with the old dictum if you didn't notice the ref he had a good game. Unfortunately Hardjowasito is remembered even 33 years after rising to prominence during a World Cup Qualifier played in New Zealand.
Today the idea of an Indonesian ref officiating at any game outside its shores is far fetched and we are not even talking about the current FIFA imposed sanction. It has been a long time since any major tournament has felt the need to call up an Indonesian and I am sure there must be a pretty good reason when you consider how political the body can be when it comes to doling out positions.
Back in the 1980s it seems officials were less reticent. The Jakarta born Hardjowasito, who boasts wiki pages in French and Hungarian but not English or Indonesian, was called up for the Asian Cup in 1980 then being hosted by Kuwait, at that time making a splash on the world game for the first time in its history.
The first game Hardjowasito took charge of was between Malaysia and North Korea with the Malaysians equalising in the last minute through Abdul Ali to salvage a point.
He must have impressed because the next time he took his whistle and his pea on to the pitch was for the final when hosts Kuwait defeated South Korea 3-0 when the Koreans were not quite the disciplined outfit they are these days.
Hardjowasito next appears on the international in April 1981 when he is officiating the World Cup Qualifier between North Korea and Thailand played in...Kuwait, a game the Thais lost 5-1. He followed that up with a trip to Fiji where the hosts lost 4-1 against Australia in another World Cup Qualifier.
Then came Auckland in October in 1981. Hardjowasito was given the game between New Zealand and Kuwait
who at the time were favourites to win the group and go on to the World Cup itself in Spain the following year.
It was a game to be mored in controversy. In the second half Hardjowasito gave two controversial penalties to Kuwait, the first was saved after the second converted. Before the second a fan invaded the pitch and threw a can at the ref and ran off seemingly at leisure despite the ref giving half hearted chase! Tempers were boiling, at least among the New Zealand players.
The ref walked off the pitch and threatened to call off the tie complaining about the lack of security. New Zealand FA official Charles Dempsey
got involved, telling the ref ' If you call this game off, it's the last game you will referee, He looked at
my Fifa badge - he had no idea what my position was - and I added: 'I'm
warning you. Call this game off and you have had it.
'I had no authority to say that because I was not the match inspector. But I had to bluff it.'
Kuwait went on to score a second and win the tie 2-1 but recriminations lasted long after.
Steve Wooddin had give the home side the lead, a sweetly struck volley from 18 yards out but the fun began in the second half and how.
A headed clearance from inside the New Zealand six yard area bounced off Steve Sumner and Hardjowasito, looking along the line, had no hesitation pointing to the spot. 'It was ball to arm,'' Sumner later said. 'Someone cleared the ball in our box and it hit me on the arm. There was no intent on my part.' Richard Wilson in goal for the home side hadn't read the script, of there was one, and he saved the spot kick, diving to his left and pushing the ball away.
A few minutes later and the ref was at it again, giving a penalty as a defender turned away from a shot. Play was held up for nine minutes as the ref walked off the pitch and threatened to call off the tie complaining about the lack of security.
New Zealand FA official Charles Dempsey
got involved, telling the ref ' If you call this game off, it's the last game you will referee, He looked at
my Fifa badge - he had no idea what my position was - and I added: 'I'm
warning you. Call this game off and you have had it.
'I had no authority to say that because I was not the match inspector. But I had to bluff it.'
When play resumed Kuwait scored, went on to score a second and won the game 2-1.
Assistant coach Kevin Fallon said 'I felt cheated that day, no doubt about it. They were penalties you couldn't get away from...sometimes if I head a ball as hard as I can at you right there, you can't disappear, it's gonna hit you. You didnt play the ball, the ball played you.'
When the ref blew the whistle to mark the end of the game policemen ran on to protect him from irate fans who tried to get at him while a Thai linesman Nobnom Ausukont was cut in the face.
Rumours flew after the game with one suggesting the Kuwaiti team had arrived in New Zealand on their own private jet, par for the course these days, with a briefcase full of money but later left without it. Obviously there is no proof this happened and in those days people were, despite their anger at the refs performance, more likely to believe the ref just had a bad day at the office than believe anything more sinister.
Sumner was one of those who liked to think the best of people. ' Back then we accepted things a little easier than players do now. I
remember thinking at the time that this referee was an officious bloke
interpreting things a little differently.'
After the game the head of the Kuwait Football Association was likewise sanguine.
Sheikh Fahad Al Ahmed Al Jaber Al Sabah, later to earn notoriety for walking on to the pitch during Kuwait's World Cup with France in 1982, said 'everywhere in the world the losing spectators have to find a reason. If we had lost, none of this would have happened.'
As it happened both Kuwait and New Zealand went on to represent Asia and Oceana at the 1982 World Cup but for Hardjowasito things got a bit quieter for a few years.
In 1984 he was dusting off his passport again, this time for Singapore and the Olympic Games Qualifiers where he was reported to have had a good game reffing South Korea v Saudi Arabia.
'I thought Sudarso did not make any major mistake in what maybe considered a difficult match,' said Yap Boon Chuan
, coaching committee chairman of the Football Association of Singapore. 'The only error was the controversial penalty awarded to Saudi Arabia in the second half from which the Saudis made no mistake.'
Saudi Arabia won the game 5-4 and finished top of the group; a group which incidentally also featured New Zealand and Kuwait!
Early in the following year he was back in Singapore, this time for more World Cup Qualifiers. He took charge of Singapore v North Korea which ended in a 1-1 draw before running the line at Singapore v Japan a few weeks later, a game the Japanese won 3-1. In April he was in Brunei watching over Hong Kong defeating the hosts 5-1.
And then he pretty much falls off the radar. No doubt he would have been active in Indonesia's domestic leagues but records are few and far between. Instead all we have is the wasit known as Hardjowasito, some controversy and little else.
Sunday, June 21, 2015
Sunrise Of Java Cup 2015
Persewangi Banuwangi are hosting a tournament during the fasting month and they have invited some big guns to join them.
Arema and Bali United have been asked as has the Under 23 side which reached the semi finals at the recent SEA Games.
However due to FIFA sanctions, the Under 23s will apparently be known as Garuda All Stars.
Banyuwangi is to be found on the east coast of Java where the island gets close to Bali and no doubt organisers will be hoping to attract fans from the island as well as Arema supporters
Saturday, June 20, 2015
AFC Cup Quarter Final Draw
25/08 Al Qadsia v Al Jaish, Johor Darul Tazim v South China
26/08 Al Kuwait v Kitchee, Istiklol v Pahang
15/09 Al Jaish v Al Qadsia, South China v Johor Darul Tazim
16/09 Pahang v Istiklol, Kitchee v Al Kuwait
Kuwaiti clubs have dominated this trophy in the last few years while Hong Kong and Malaysia sides have yet to reach a final.
2014 Al Qadsia
2013 Al Kuwait - Al Qadsia lost in the final
2012 Al Kuwait
2011 Al Kuwait lost in the final
2010 Al Qadsia lost in the final
2009 Al Kuwait
Wednesday, June 17, 2015
Four Points For Singapore Away Days
Football is the most fragile of mistresses. Your team plays badly or loses and feet are stamped, doors slammed and fingers are stuck in ears to display a primitive anger. You have been let down, you are hurt and you need people to show you are hurt; even the least narcissistic have been known to fold their arms, knot their eyebrows and say 'humph' after a loss. Or you get pissed.
But win? Oh boy, you can't wait to rip off the clothes, let it all hang and have a quick romp in the hay or on the kitchen table. You need to share that victory with a release of emotion, something that can make the feeling last just a bit longer. Or you get pissed.
Not that long ago, in fact just a few days back, the Singapore football fraternity, except Mabel who was sick, was beating its collective chest and wailing at how shit life was...the cause for this mass outpouring of grief being their exit from the SEA Games, a competition for Under 23s. It seems many expected the Young Lions to win the bloody thing 'cos they were hosting the bloody thing or because the players had been on stints overseas.
Meanwhile the proper national team was in Cambodia defeating the hosts 4-0 in front of a partisan 63,000 crowd. Impressive stuff but mostly overlooked 'cos of the perceived national humiliation closer to home.
Singapore then set off to play Japan. Another big crowd, 57,000 +++, another clean sheet and whaddayaknow? Singapore, them coached by Bernd Stang who has been on the end of calls for him to step down, were top of their group and had four points in the bag.
Now obviously this is early days in the World Cup/Asian Cup Qualification but to have four points in the bag from two away games? That ain't a bad start. Not bad at all.
To the glory keeper Izwan Mahbud, once of the much derided Young Lions! In fact much of the squad that travelled to Cambodia and Japan came up through the ranks of the Young Lions, a developmental side competing in the SLeague. A tad harsh then, perhaps, for some to call the Young Lions rubbish 'cos they failed to get out of the group stage at the SEA Games?
Syria will obviously be a threat and Singapore face them in October in Oman. Traditionally South East Asian nations have struggled when playing in the Middle East and Stang will have his work cut out for this one but perhaps the small crowd that could be anticipated could work to his, and his team's, advantage.
For now Singapore can bask in the glory of being number one in the group for at least a couple of months. There is still a long way between now and then and for the Singapore players, from playing in front of crowds of 63,000 and 57,000 they can look forward to the glamour of the Singapore League Cup where fans tend to stay home.
Lions All The Way. Eh?
Sunday, June 14, 2015
Thailand's Open Doors, Open Minds Too Much For Insular Indonesia
Well, Indonesia got taught a football lesson sure enough by the Thais in their SEA Games semi final in Singapore although to be fair it was always on the cards. And the loss can in no way be blamed on the government, on BOPI or even KFC unless the players were overdosing on fried chicken in the lead up to the game.
New money has poured into Thai football in recent years. Admittedly you can question the motives of the regional mafia types who have discovered the game since it was invented in 2009 but what you can't question is where much of that money has gone. I strongly recommend someone from somewhere in Indonesian football get off their butts and fly to Bangkok and tour some of the clubs in the country. See the investment that is going on, investment in stadiums, investment in youth.
Investment it seems is forbidden in Indonesia. No one it seems is ready to put their hands in their pocket to develop a footballing infrastructure despite the lip service given to developing football. Phnom Penh Crown recently hosted a youth tournement...I won't bother insulting your intelligence by asking how many Indonesian clubs sent sides.
There are very few Indonesian football clubs. Most who enter the professional set up are built for a season on short term contracts. How the hell can you plan for the future like that? An agency story recently pointed out Persipura as in the football club had dismantled itself following the political mess engulfing the game. Nope, the team was broken up. The club will be back next time they put a team together!
Back in the early years of the 21st century several Thai players tried their luck overseas. We are talking A listers like Therdsak Chaiman, Datsakorn Thonglao and others headed to Vietnam, Singapore to earn better money of course but also to add to their football experience. A couple even made it to Indonesia like Phaiboon Thiabma, Kosin and Suchin Nuchnao.
Their return to the land of smiles coincided with more money flowing into the game and these players were highly sought after...not just cos they were bloody good but because they brought experiences considered valuable for the domestic game.
Look how many foreign coaches there are in Thailand and there have been in recent years. Including the ones on gardening leave!
Indonesia? Yep, the odd player heads to Malaysia. A country with a similar language and culture. But that's about it. For many players it seems the prospect of missing bakso
and teh botol
trumps adding to their professional cv and becoming a better player. And it seems if they do finally take the plunge and go overseas they are not trusted by the national team selectors anyway because, umm, well I dunno why.
It's a shame. With no domestic football the best players, and I am thinking Evan Dimas, Ramdhani Lestalahu etc, should be on the phone to agents looking for clubs in the region and not wait for officials in their own country to get their act together. These are promising young players, the last thing they want is their careers ruined by knuckled heads with no interest in football which is what happened to earlier generations.
No one has shown they can run football for the sake of football. Yes there will always be nepotism and corruption but there also needs to be an element of football going on. The current Women's World Cup was heavily promoted by Sepp Blatter for example. But in Indonesia there is not even any pretense that anything is about football.
If my translating skills haven't grown rusty the biggest news for me is the marketing guy at Persib stepping down. He is just the sort of person football needs to grow. But nope, he has moved on to his own career. There aren't that many like him in the game, to lose just one ain't good.
Thai football looks and smells professional while lacking its own culture at the moment beyond girls in hot pants and selfies. Indonesia has its own football culture but looks and smells amateurish. Until a professional group of people can be bought in to run the game for the sake of football then nothing is going to change anytime soon. A win over Singapore will be celebrated with the gutso of a real trophy but a fall is never far away.
Friday, June 12, 2015
Where Now For Evan Dimas?
Evan Dimas has been making headlines in Indonesia for a couple of years now. Ever since he was part of the national Under 19 side that actually won a trophy in fact.
Now he is becoming a name around South East Asia. He scored for Indonesia during the ASEAN Football Championships in Hanoi last year and now he has scored in the SEA Games, netting the winner against hosts Singapore that guaranteed a semi final spot for the Garuda Muda.
Whatever happens at the SEA Games, win the bloody thing or get thumped by the Thais in the semi final, Evan Dimas needs to start thinking what he should do to develop his career. He has shown this uncanny knack of scoring in big games, that suggests there is something about the lad that is worth nurturing.
And that nurturing ain't going to happen in Indonesia where the league has been halted while the government and the PSSI engage in a pissing contest.
The 20 year old has played just two league games for his club side Persebaya and it is difficult to see where the third game will come from. He was scoring for Indonesia before he played for his club side!
Maybe he should follow in the footsteps of another Persebaya talent. Andik Vermansyah is now in his second season with Selangor in Malaysia and is relishing professional football in another country. You know, football where players get paid on time, where games aren't moved at the last minute, fans don't boycott teams over ownership stuff...all that kind of stuff.
Evan needs to be looking overseas. But instead of Malaysia with its similar culture why not think further afield and try the Thai Premier League, following in the footsteps of ex Persebaya player Greg Nwokolo.
The last thing Evan needs to do in terms of his football career is return to Indonesia and wait for bickering men in suits to decide what to do next. It is his career, he needs to take control of it and if that means playing overseas then go for it.
Aide Bites Bullet After Indonesia Loss
Singapore's SEA Games campaign ended at the Jalan Besar Stadium when a moment of magic from Evan Dimas consigned them to defeat and ensured it was to be Indonesia who would play Thailand in the semi final.
In the wake of the game coach Aide Iskander announced he had stepped down as coach.
Singapore had been blasted by the football public after losing their opening game against Myanmar but even a win over Cambodia couldn't soothe the passions of a handful who seemed to expect they win every single game playing with a Barcelona style swagger.
But as I wrote
a few days ago we will not know how successful Aide's work has been until a few years down the road as the players fill out and mature.
At the end of the day the SEA Games is a tournament for Under 23s. It is not on a par with the World Cup, the Asian Cup or even the ASEAN Football Championships and going out at the group stage is not the humiliation some people are suggesting.
It is worth pointing out on the same day Singapore's Under 23s were bowing out of a competition at home the full national side was winning 4-0 in front of 63,000 in Cambodia in their first game on the road to Russia/UAE. And much of that team cut its teeth in the SEA Games without winning it.
In the wake of Aide's resignation the FAS have said they hope to change his mind over the coming days.
Kuwait And Singapore Start Qualifying Campaigns In Style
Lebanon v Kuwait 0-1 (Yousef Naser) 15,215
When Lebanon apppointed Montengran Miodrag Radulovic as their new coach for the World Cup/Asian Cup Qualifiers they would have hoped they were hiring not just an experienced coach but someone with the inside track on Kuwait, another nation in their group. Radulovic had been enticed from Al Jahra in the Kuwaiti Premier League just a few weeks before this opening game on the road to Russia/UAE but it was one of his former players from an earlier stint at Kazma who came back to haunt him right at the death.
Things started brightly for the Lebanese. Roared on by a near full house they probed and pressed, going close on a number of occassions. But, and cue the cliche this is football, the more chances they spured the more likely it would be the visitors who would nick the points.
And so it proved. A long hopeful punt forward caused uncertainty in the home side's defence with both defender and goalkeeper committed. 24 year old substitute striker Yousef Naser, who plays for Kazma, took advantage of the uncertainty to score the only goal of the game with just four minutes remaining.
Malaysia v Timor Leste 1-1 (Safee Sali; Ramon de Lima Saro) 5,000
It was to be a night of late goals. Safee Sali had given Malaysia the lead in the first half but Timor Leste, led by Yousef Naser's strike partner at Kazma in the Kuwaiti Premier League Patrick Fabiano, proved a tough nut to crack with defender Ramon equalising in injury time.
Disappointing crowd as well despite calls on line for fans to fill the stadium.
Malaysia host Palestine next week and will be hoping for a win to get their campaign on track. They will not however be taking much heart from Palestime's battling display against Saudi Arabi in their opener. They may have lost 3-2 defeat came in a heart breaking manner after they had equalised themselves right at the end of the game.
Cambodia v Singapore 0-4 (Khairul Amri, Safuwan Baharudin, Fazrul Nawaz) 63,000
Of course with Singapore due to travel on to Japan for their next qualify you could argue anything other than a win in Phnom Penh was not on the menu. Despite the criticism that follows in the Lions' wake the team knuckled down and did a job in front of a massive crowd at the Olympic Stadium.
And can 2015 get any better for Safuwan? A successful loan spell in Australia with Melbourne City he quickly settled into the Singapore way of doing things and netted a brace here to add to his burgeoning reputation. Surely another move is on the cards?
Unfortunately the winning margin was not enough to put the Lions on top of the group, albeit for a few days. Syria defeated Afghanistan 6-0!
Thursday, June 11, 2015
Kuwait's White Eelephant Stadium
since its completion back in 2007, Kuwait's 60,000 capacity Jaber
Al-Ahmad International Stadium has been little more than a vacant white
In stark contrast to the many
ex-Olympic and World Cup sporting landmarks that have gone derelict
following a fleeting crowd rush, the national stadium of this Gulf Arab
monarchy of roughly four million has only ever hosted one senior level
match since opening.
The curious lack of activity has
turned the mammoth steel structure into a symbol of bureaucracy and a
penchant for silence on hot topics in the region. Whispers on the
culpability of the stadium's closure have been plentiful (mainly to do
with structural problems), while definitive public statements have been
"It's a sad story; it's a work
of art," Louay Al-Kharafi, a board member of Kharafi Group, the
industrial conglomerate tasked with building the stadium, told CNN from
his office in downtown Kuwait City.
Kharafi Group won the bid to build the stadium back in 2004 for a relatively paltry $189 million
(by contrast, Emirates Stadium in London was completed in 2006 for $650
million). The company operates in over 25 countries and had a hand in
the build out of South Africa's 2010 World Cup.
structural is wrong with the stadium," said Al-Kharafi, while remaining
adamant that no construction errors were committed by his team, nor had
they ever faced any lawsuits over the construction of the stadium
levied by the government. In fact, he said, the stadium has been ready
to go all along.
"It's simple; if there is a fault in the structure, just ask the contractor to fix it," he added. "No one asked."
Yet there has been open talk
in Kuwait since November 6, 2010 when 58,604 people filled the grounds
to watch the final of the 2010 Asian Federation Cup (won by Syrian club
Al-Ittihad -- still the only officially sanctioned match ever played on
the pitch) that a few of the stadium's support columns had been
In January, CNN visited Jaber
Al Ahmad Stadium and had a tour of its facilities, led by Khalid
Bonashi, the stadium's security chief whose glass-paneled office offers
dramatic field-level views of the architectural gem, designed to
resemble a traditional dhow fishing boat from a distance.
a bright blue sky overlooking the pitch, empty seats fanned across the
horizon, save for the odd maintenance crew member. A fervent Arsenal
supporter, Bonashi recalled his tour of Emirates Stadium in north
London, when he paid special attention to features like its public
announcement system, digitally triggered turnstiles, and luxurious
Back in Kuwait, Bonashi
added enhancements of his own, including a phone ticketing application,
rail bars in front of each level of seating to tackle crowd control
(not uncommon in Europe), as well as a grand VIP concourse complete with
a golf-cart custom ordered from the United States to roll dignitaries
onto the pitch for special occasions.
original drawings called for an elevator to descend the cart onto
ground level from the VIP hall, however, despite the presence of a
large-enough shaft, the plan was scraped.
he may not have been privy to investigative results, Bonashi considered
the facility safe enough to host matches at the time, maintaining that
rumors were at fault for crowds avoiding a February 2013 stadium-hosted
attempt to break the Guinness World Record for a human flag.
The stadium has been closed to the public ever since.
on that brisk winter day, everything in the stadium -- from the
perfectly manicured natural grass, to the fine sand on the athletics
long jump box, to the clear water in the hydro-therapy pool, and the
sparkling blue carpeting in the VIP box -- looked immaculate.
touring the complex, two cracks underneath the pedestrian walkway that
circles the stadium were pointed out. It was clear that the columns had
been worked on, perhaps to test their strength, and subsequently
fortified. Whether those columns were at fault for the stadium's closure
-- or whether something else was to blame -- was entirely unclear,
"We've examined those
cracks," said Al-Kharafi. "We broke down the cracks (to check) the steel
and it's sound and safe." Al-Kharafi noted that structural integrity
tests were carried out with the cooperation of government agencies, and
that they had all passed. CNN was not able to verify the test results.
Football Bounty For Fans In KL
Undoubtedly today is a great day to be in the Malaysian capital city Kuala Lumpur with some high profile World Cup stroke Asian Cup qualifiers taking place in and around the capital over the next few days.
It all kicks off today with Malaysia hosting Timor Leste at the Bukit Jalil Stadium. After calling for a boycott of the meaningless friendlies against holidaying EPL teams, just 28,000 bothered turning out to watch small Middlesex side Tottenham, Malaysian fan groups are calling for a full house against Timor Leste...and a full house there means approaching 100,000.
Timor Leste may be little known outside of, well, everywhere really, but the games Malaysia to cast their collective over a certain Patrick Fabiano. The 27 year old Brazilian born striker turned heads last season in the Kuwaiti Premier League when he netted 21 goals playing for unheralded Kazma.
It was a season that must have had a few of the bigger sides, and we are talking Al Qadsia, Al Arabi and champions Al Kuwait, make notes and given the Kuwaiti sides success in the AFC Cup in recent years surely it won't be long before Fabiano makes even more headlines. A good performance at the Bukit Jalil in front of a passionate crowd
can only add to his reputation.
One player who doesn't need his reputation enhancing is United Arab Emirates' Omar Abdulrahman
The UAE are in KL as part of their preparations for their own World Cup qualifier against Timor Leste next Tuesday and later today sees them take on South Korea in what could be a thrilling friendly between two of Asia's top sides.
It has been a long season for the UAE players with several involved in the President's Cup that only reached its climax a couple of weeks back. Throw in a pretty decent run at the AFC Asian Cup run in Australia back in January and there could be an excuse for some tired legs. But there have been suggestions the current crop of players have, for all their undoubted talent, have underperformed internationally and now, with a World Cup at stake, should be the time for them to step up to the plate (yawn, cliche).
Obviously the die hard Malaysian fan will want to catch their own side in action against Timor Leste and Palestine next Tuesday but for those who can't get tickets then catching the UAE with Omar in, hopefully, full flow, will not be second best entertainment, I guarantee. All they need to do is put a certain 5-0 reverse
Tuesday, June 09, 2015
World Cup Qualifiers Beckon
30/05 Bangladesh v Singapore 1-2
06/06 Singapore v Brunei 5-1
11/06 Cambodia v Singapore
16/06 Japan v Singapore
26/03 Oman v Malaysia 6-0
06/06 Malaysia v Hong Kong 0-0
11/06 Malaysia v Timor Leste
16/06 Malaysia v Palestine
24/05 Thailand v Vietnam 1-0
05/06 Thailand v Bahrain 1-1
16/06 Chinese Taipei v Thailand
30/03 Colombia v Kuwait 3-1
05/06 Jordan v Kuwait 2-2
11/06 Lebanon v Kuwait